Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Advertising

Search




Advanced Search


Blog Roll
Who's My Legislator?

Virginia Blogs
Augusta Free Press
Bacon's Rebellion
Blue Ridge Caucus
Coarse Cracked Corn
Crew of 42
DemRulz
Dixie Pig
Equality Loudoun
Greater Greater Washington
Loudoun Progress
Moonhowlings
Not Larry Sabato
Ox Road South Blog
Pilot on Politics" blog
Richmonder
Richmond Sunlight
RTD Virginia Politics blog
Roanoke Times blog
Shad Plank
Vivian Paige
Waldo Jaquith
Waldo's VA Political Blogroll


Find more about Weather in Arlington, VA
Click for weather forecast

A Quibble with Ezra Klein on (Not) Raising the Retirement Age

by: lowkell

Mon Nov 26, 2012 at 12:10:49 PM EST


Before I get to my quibble with Ezra Klein, I first strongly recommend that everyone read his column, "Why rich guys want to raise the retirement age". The bottom line is that it's galling to listen to rich people like Goldman Sachs CEO Lloyd Blankfein talk about raising the retirement age, when in no way will folks like Blankfein ever feel the pain from doing so:
They don't want to retire at age 65, and they don't have short life expectancies, and they're not mainly relying on Social Security for their retirement income. They're bravely advocating a cut they'll never feel.
Meanwhile, as Klein correctly points out, you don't hear the Blankfeins of the world talking about lifting the cap on Social Security taxes (currently at the first $110,000 of income, even if you make $16.1 million per year, as Blankfein does). Doing that, as Klein explains, "would do three times as much to solve Social Security's shortfall as raising the retirement age to 70." In fact, Klein adds, "it would, in one fell swoop, close Social Security's solvency gap for the next 75 years."

In other words, next time you hear a politician, of either party, talk about raising the retirement age without talking about raising the cap on Social Security taxes from $110,000, feel free to tell them to take a long stroll off a very short pier into an extremely deep lake.

So what's my quibble with Ezra Klein on this subject? Basically, it's the part I've bolded in the following sentence by Klein: "One of the things the richest society the world has ever known can buy is a decent retirement for people who don't have jobs they love and who don't want to work forever."

With all due respect to Ezra Klein, for whom I have the greatest respect and admiration, I don't believe this is the correct framing of the issue. Instead, my view is that for most working people, it's not so much an issue of whether they "love" their jobs or "want to work forever," it's that they're sick, in pain, physically exhausted, needing to care for sick spouses or other loved ones, etc. In many cases, that's why they NEED - not so much "want" - to retire. And that's exactly what they've earned by paying into the system for decades. Sure, if everyone had office jobs that were mentally stimulating, not physically taxing, and financially (highly) rewarding, a lot more people would "want" to keep working until they're 65, 70 or beyond. But most people - certainly those in the lower income brackets - don't happen to have jobs like that. Perhaps the Blankfeins of the world would care to switch for a while, walk a mile in the other man's moccasins so to speak, and then let us know what he thinks about raising the retirement age?

Bottom line: I have a quibble with Ezra Klein's otherwise spot-on analysis. I have a lot more than a quibble with the Lloyd Blankfeins of the world.

lowkell :: A Quibble with Ezra Klein on (Not) Raising the Retirement Age
Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

8th CD Dem Candidates
*Don Beyer *Lavern Chatman *Adam Ebbin *Bill Euille *Charniele Herring *Patrick Hope *Derek Hyra *Mark Levine *Alfonso Lopez *Bruce Shuttleworth *Mark Sickles *Nancy Najarian *Satish Korpe
Advertising

FOLLOW BLUE VIRGINIA on SOCIAL MEDIA


Donate to Blue Virginia

About
The purpose of Blue Virginia is to cover Virginia politics from a progressive and Democratic perspective. This is a group blog and a community blog. We invite everyone to comment here, but please be aware that profanity, personal attacks, bigotry, insults, rudeness, frequent unsupported or off-point statements, "trolling" (NOTE: that includes outright lies, whether about climate science, or what other people said, or whatever), and "troll ratings abuse" (e.g., "troll" rating someone simply because you disagree with their argument) are not permitted and, if continued, will lead to banning. For more on trolling, see the Daily Kos FAQs. Also note that diaries may be deleted if they do not contain at least 2 solid paragraphs of original text; if not, please use the comments section of a relevant diary. For more on writing diaries, click here. Thanks, and enjoy!

P.S. You can contact us at lowell@raisingkaine.com and you can subscribe to Lowell's Twitter feed here. If you'd like to subscribe to Miles Grant's Twitter feed, click here. For Teacherken, click here. For Kindler, click here.

P.P.S. To see the Blue Virginia archive, please click here. To see the Raising Kaine archive, please click here. To see the Blue Commonwealth archive, please click here.



RSS Feed

Subscribe to Blue Virginia - Front Page


Real Time Web Analytics
Powered by: SoapBlox